Most companies in a market sell the same thing in the same way, and compete on small differences. This Practice looks for a different way to deliver what customers value. When it works, customers start expecting the new way from everyone, and competitors have to change how they operate to keep up.

A tool that supports it

Sector Disruption is a way of acting, and several tools can feed it. One built for the job is the “Four Actions Framework,” from W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne, the authors of Blue Ocean Strategy.

The framework asks four questions about the way an industry works. Which factors that the industry takes for granted should be eliminated? Which should be reduced well below the standard? Then it turns around. Which factors should be raised well above the standard, and which should be created that the industry has never offered?

For this Practice, the four answers together describe a new offer. Eliminating and reducing free up money and time. Raising and creating are where that money and time go.

When to use it

Use it in annual planning, or when the whole market is fighting over price. The signal is a strategy meeting where every option on the table is a version of what competitors already do.

It takes the standing to propose a change in the business model, and evidence that customers want it. A small test with a few customers comes before the big move.

How to use it

  1. List what every company in your market offers and how it charges.
  2. Answer the four questions in order, one line each: what to eliminate, what to reduce, what to raise, what to create. Give the first question the most time. Dropping something the whole market takes for granted is the answer people avoid.
  3. Put the four answers together into one offer a customer would understand in a sentence.
  4. Work out the cost, and say what the company stops doing to pay for it. This is the hard part.
  5. Test it with a few customers, then take it to the people who decide the budget.

Example

An accounting firm with 40 people is losing small clients to cheaper firms. In the planning meeting, the options are familiar.

One partner runs the four questions first. Eliminate: billing by the hour, which no client likes. Reduce: in-person meetings, from monthly to twice a year. Raise: response time, to an answer the same day. Create: a 20-minute cash review every month, which no firm in the region offers.

The usual way “Let’s match their prices and add a loyalty discount.”
The Practice “I’m proposing we stop billing by the hour. Clients pay a fixed monthly fee and get an answer the same day. Every month they also get a cash review. Nobody in our region sells accounting this way. Here’s what it costs, and here’s what we stop doing to pay for it.”

The partners move a third of the year’s budget to the new model. Within a year, two competing firms have published fixed monthly prices of their own.

Phrases you can use

  • “What does everyone in our market do that customers would be glad to lose?”
  • “What could we offer that nobody here has offered before?”
  • “If we stopped doing this, what would it free up?”
  • “Could a customer repeat this offer in one sentence?”
  • “Here’s what we stop doing to pay for it.”
  • For a leader, when someone does it: “You proposed a different game and showed how to fund it. What did the first customers say?”

How to know it worked

The decision shows in the budget, with money moved from the old model to the new one. Customers start describing your offer to others in a sentence. Over time, competitors change their own pricing or service to answer it.

In a Skill Deck Track on Strategy, a person can choose this Practice, and the meetings they already have show when they use it.

skilldeck.ai