Most decisions are judged by their first effect, the one the decision was made to cause. The trouble usually comes one step later, in a team that wasn’t in the room. This Practice follows a decision past its first effect and asks what each result will cause in turn. What it finds goes into the plan before the decision is approved.
A tool that supports it
Second-Order Logic is a way of thinking, and different tools can make it visible. One that fits on a single page is the “Futures Wheel,” created by the futurist Jerome Glenn.
You write the decision in the center of the page. Around it go the direct effects, each connected to the center by a line. These are the first rings. Then you take each direct effect and ask what it will cause. Those answers form the second ring, one step farther out. The finished page looks like a wheel with the decision at the hub.
Second-Order Logic lives in the outer ring. The first ring is what everyone already expects. The second is where a decision in one team turns into work for another.
When to use it
Use it before approving a decision that changes a price or a policy for customers. The signal is a proposal where every effect listed is a good one.
It takes about 20 minutes with the people who know the other teams’ work. Two rings are enough for most decisions. A third ring is mostly guessing.
How to use it
- Write the decision in the center of a page.
- Around it, write the direct effects. Ask: “What happens right away if we do this?”
- For each direct effect, ask: “And then what? Which team feels it?” Write those answers in a second ring. Going past a first ring that looks good is the hard part.
- Mark the items in the second ring that cost money or time, and talk to the team that owns each one.
- Add a plan for each marked item to the decision before it’s approved.
Example
A wholesale bakery wants more small cafes as customers. The sales lead proposes lowering the minimum order from $200 to $50.
Before the vote, the operations manager draws the wheel. The first ring has two effects: more customers and many more small orders. Then she asks what the small orders will cause. The delivery vans leave at 5 AM and must finish by 8 AM, and about 30 more stops a day won’t fit in that window. Finance would also go from 90 invoices a month to about 300.
The team approves the lower minimum with both changes. Deliveries still finish by 8 AM.
Phrases you can use
- “That’s the first effect. What does that cause?”
- “Which team feels this one step later?”
- “Who isn’t in this room and will get more work from this?”
- “Before we approve it, can we plan for those two effects?”
- “I’m in favor. I want us to see what comes with it.”
- For a leader, when someone does it: “You looked one step past the decision. What did the other team say when you told them?”
How to know it worked
The decision is approved together with a plan for its side effects, and the team that carries them knew in advance. In the weeks after, fewer surprises come back to the people who decided. Over time, proposals arrive with a second ring already drawn.
In a Skill Deck Track on Decision Making, a person can choose this Practice, and the meetings they already have show when they use it.
skilldeck.ai


