A decision framed as “should we do this or not?” has only one option in it. The team spends the meeting arguing for and against that one idea, and nobody looks for a better one. This Practice puts more real options on the table before the choice is made. With something to compare, the same team often picks a path nobody had mentioned at the start.

A tool that supports it

Option Expansion is a behavior, and you can build it in more than one way. A quick tool is the “Vanishing Options Test,” which Chip Heath and Dan Heath describe in their book Decisive.

The test is one question. You take the option everyone is debating and pretend it has disappeared. Then you ask what else you could do to get the same result. Because the favorite is gone, people stop defending it and start thinking about the need behind it.

Option Expansion lives in what comes after the question. The answers go on the table next to the original idea, and the decision is made among all of them.

When to use it

Use it when a decision reaches the team as a yes or a no. The signal is in the wording: “Should we buy it or not?” or “Do we hire or don’t we?”

It suits choices with real money or months of work attached. For a small choice that’s easy to undo, one option is fine.

How to use it

  1. Write the decision the way it’s being asked. If it ends in “or not,” there’s one option on the table.
  2. Take that option away. Ask the group: “Say we can’t do this at all. What else would get us what we need?”
  3. Write down at least two answers before anyone judges them. Holding back the judgment is the hard part.
  4. Put the original option back beside the new ones.
  5. Compare all of them on the same two points, like cost and time, and choose.

Example

A landscaping company has one truck and more work than it can reach. The operations manager brings a question to the weekly team meeting.

One of the crew leads runs the test first. Say the truck can’t be bought. What else gets two crews to their jobs? The busy season is four months long, and a truck rents for $1,800 a month. That’s one answer. The other is a new route plan, where one truck drops the first crew at 7 AM and comes back for the second.

The usual way “Should we buy a second truck or not? It’s $45,000.”
The Practice “Before we vote on the truck, here are two other ways to get both crews out. We can rent a truck for the four busy months, for $7,200. Or we can change the routes so one truck serves both crews. Which of the three fits this year?”

The team rents for the season. In October they’ll decide about buying, with four months of real numbers.

Phrases you can use

  • “Right now we have one option and a yes or no. What else could we do?”
  • “Say this option is off the table. How would we solve it then?”
  • “What are we really trying to get here?”
  • “Let’s get two more ideas down before we judge any of them.”
  • “Can we put all the options side by side, with what each one costs?”
  • For a leader, when someone does it: “You brought us more than a yes or no. Which option surprised you?”

How to know it worked

The team chooses among options, and the question on the table no longer ends in “or not.” Sometimes the original idea still wins, and now people know what it beat. Over time, proposals start arriving with alternatives already attached.

In a Skill Deck Track on Decision Making, a person can choose this Practice, and the meetings they already have show when they use it.

skilldeck.ai