Many discussions stall because each person argues from their own preference. The decision often depends on someone who isn’t there, like a client or a senior leader. This Practice brings that person’s goals into the conversation. The group then has something outside itself to line up behind, and the debate about preferences loses its grip.

A tool that supports it

Chess Player Logic is a way of acting, and more than one tool can prepare you for it. A quick one is the “Empathy Map,” a method from the book Gamestorming, by Dave Gray, Sunni Brown and James Macanufo.

You draw a circle for the person and write their name and role in it. Next to it goes one question you’d like them to answer. Then you divide the circle into sections. One holds what the person is thinking and feeling, and another what they say and do. A last one holds what they hear from others. You fill each section with details you’ve observed. The authors’ advice is to avoid putting your own words in the person’s mouth.

For this Practice, the map is how you earn the right to speak for someone absent. What you bring to the room is a fact about that person, with where you got it.

When to use it

Use it when a group is stuck between options and the choice will be judged by someone outside the meeting. The signal is a debate where every sentence starts with “I think” or “I’d prefer.”

It depends on what you really know about the person. If the map is mostly guesses, the next step is to ask them.

How to use it

  1. Name the person outside the room whose need matters most to this decision.
  2. Write one question: “What does this person need from this by a certain date?”
  3. Fill in the map with what you’ve heard them say and seen them do. Add what they hear from the people they answer to. Mark anything that’s a guess.
  4. In the meeting, state one fact from the map and where it comes from. Speaking for someone absent without inventing their opinion is the hard part.
  5. Connect that fact to the choice on the table.

Example

A software company is building a product for a school district. The team has argued for two meetings about what to build first: a reading report for teachers or an app for parents. Design wants the app. Engineering wants the report.

The account manager maps the superintendent, who signed the contract. Her question for the map is what the superintendent needs by spring. Under saying and doing: on the first call, she asked twice about the reading report. Under hearing: her school board has been asking why reading scores are flat, and she presents to the board on March 12.

The usual way “I still think the app is the better product.”
The Practice “Can I bring in the superintendent? She presents to her board on March 12, and they’ve been asking about reading scores. On our first call she asked about the reading report twice. The app can’t ship before May. I’d build the report first, so she has it in March.”

The team agrees in ten minutes and moves the app to the next phase.

Phrases you can use

  • “Who decides whether this was a success, and what are they hoping for?”
  • “Can I bring in someone who isn’t here?”
  • “On our last call, this is what she asked about.”
  • “What does he have to show his own boss, and when?”
  • “If she were in this room, which option would she pick?”
  • For a leader, when someone does it: “You reminded us who this is for. How did you know what she needed?”

How to know it worked

The group stops trading preferences and starts testing options against the absent person’s goal. A decision follows quickly, and nobody feels they lost. Over time, people open discussions by asking what the client or the leader needs before giving their own view.

In a Skill Deck Track on Influence, a person can choose this Practice, and the meetings they already have show when they use it.

skilldeck.ai